May 26, 2022

The anti-gender identification act came after Twitter of the reform lobby group Forwomen Scotland criticized an advertisement by Green MSP, Gillian Mackay, for research and casework assistant internship with the party, which was sponsored by the disability charity Inclusion Scotland. Supported.

The concept of self-identification is central to criticism of the SNP’s planned reforms to the Gender Identity Act, with campaigners arguing that transgender people should be allowed to identify themselves because of the rights of the opposite sex. Will affect

Sign up In our Politics Newsletter

Sign up In our Politics Newsletter

Many gender critics have also dismissed it as a meaningful concept.

Labor MSP Pam Duncan-Glancy has criticized the lobby group’s attacks on job advertisements.

In a tweet, For Women Scotland said: “Praise yourself as a disabled person” for the opportunity to work with Gillian and Lorna. [Slater]! “

He further retweeted a man who said that such a job advertisement would “annoy” people with the idea of ​​’self-identifying’ in a job using asthma or dyslexia.

However, Scottish Labor’s Palm Duncan-Glensi says ‘self-ID’ is preferred by the disability movement, and any attempt to “prove” people’s medical history is “ridiculous and intrusive”. Will cause

He said: “Self-ID has long been a priority in the disability movement.

“No one needs to provide their medical history, just accept who they are. We’ve seen how far it takes us, it leads us to ATOS-type satire and interference. Which is unacceptable.

“It’s also an important issue of principle, recognizing that not all defects are visible, and gives people a place to ‘come out’, to identify themselves as disabled in front of others so that they too can be part of the community.” Be part and be accepted for who they are.

“It is about acceptance and tolerance, and it has always been, that these are the principles by which, in a progressive society, any person with a disability – or indeed any person – should be able to enjoy and support it. Should.”

Gillian McKay, who is deaf, said she was proud to be offered an internship.

She said: “My inclusion in Scotland as a young woman with a disability has opened many doors for me.

“I am very proud to be in a position now to offer this experience to another young person.”

For women, Scotland was contacted for comment.

Want to hear more from the Scotsman political team? Check out the latest episode of our political podcast, The Steamy.

Editor’s message:

Thank you for reading this article. We rely more on your cooperation than ever before because the change in consumer habits caused by the Corona virus affects our advertisers.

If you haven’t already, please consider supporting our trusted, fact-checking journalism with a digital subscription.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.