A former justice secretary has said the policy of allowing male inmates who identify themselves as women to stay in the women’s prison state is “crooked”.
Former SNP cabinet minister Kenny McAskel said the practice puts vulnerable women at risk of serving time and “retromatizing” them.
The blast came as the Scottish Prison Service reaffirmed its policy of accepting a person who identifies a man as a woman, regardless of whether the prisoner is legally transgender or not. Will
In a letter to Mr. MacAscal, SPS interim chief executive Teresa Medhurst said: “The SPS ‘position is that the social gender of the detainee must be fully respected. Regardless of whether the person is in it or not, there is evidence of a gender identity certificate in custody. “
He added: “The accommodation provided should be tailored to the needs of the detainee and reflect the gender in which the detainee is currently living.”
This came after we were told how Scotland Police had revealed in a letter to Mr MacAskel that if a male assailant was identified as a woman, regardless of his legal status, he would be raped. Dari intends to record by a woman.
Author JK Rowling, an outspoken self-identification critic, later condemned the police’s behavior as “overvalued.”
The SNP-Green government has pledged to introduce new laws allowing gender self-identification by mid-2022.
Most read in Scottish News.
This means that men can be identified as women without medical examination.
The move is being opposed by some women’s rights groups due to security concerns. Pro-Trans campaigners have accused critics of being biased.
Mr McAskel wrote similar letters to Police Scotland and the SPS asking about their policy positions on suspects or detainees who they say differ from their gender.
East Lutheran MP, who now represents the Alba Party, said: “It’s ridiculous that a male perpetrator who has committed rape but who identifies himself as a woman is classified as such. Will be done
“It reduces statistics and affects justice.
“Now we have the Scottish prison service treating them like women and keeping them in women’s prisons.
‘It shakes up statistics and undermines justice’
“It simply came to our notice then.
“It’s not just a threat that protects them from predators, it’s a threat to their health.”
He added: “Prisoners who are physically male cannot be allowed access to women’s property.
“The Scottish Government’s belief should not be allowed to override the duty of caring for women prisoners, no matter the reason.”
Responding to Mr McAskel – Justice Secretary between 2007 and 2014 – Ms Madhurst said decisions on where to place trans prisoners were made in the system “on an individual basis, a multidisciplinary assessment of both risk and need”. Are notified by “.
Experts say an independent Scotland outside the European Union would be better off avoiding a tight border with England.
The SPS boss added: “Such decisions protect the well-being and rights of the individual as well as the well-being and rights of others around them, including the staff.”
A spokesman for the Scottish Government said: “It is important that people really understand the law that exists and has been in force for over a decade.”
Not all trans people have a gender identity certificate and no one needs to have one.
The current UK Equality Act, which came into force in 2010, ensures that gender reassignment is a secure feature, regardless of whether or not it has a GRC.